2026 (Junior)
- Went 2-0 at the Cactus Classic, earning ranked wins against No. 19 Georgia State and No. 20 Arizona with partner Whitmarsh.
- Big 12 Pair of the Week with Kendall Whitmarsh (2/24).
- Competed on court five at the Canyon Classic, finishing 4-0 with partner Kendall Whitmarsh. They secured ranked wins against No. 5 TCU and No. 13 Grand Canyon.
- In the fall, participated in the AVCA Pairs National Championships, playing with Reagan Hope and going 2-3.
2025 (Sophomore)
- Played in every dual this season, going 19-16 across all five courts but seeing the most time at the No. 2, 3 and 4 spots. Paired with three different Sun Devils, playing the most with Anya Pemberton.
- With Ava Williamson, had a win over the No. 3 pair from No. 4 LMU at the COE Challenge.
- Competing at the No. 4 and 5 courts, went 3-1 at the Wildcat Spring Challenge. With Pemberton, picked up a win over the No. 5 pair from No. 1 TCU.
- Went 5-0 at the No. 4 court with Haughy against Arizona and at the ASU/GCU invitational. Picked up a ranked win over No. 19 Washington.
- Picked up a win over the No. 3 pair from No. 18 Georgia State with Ava Haughy.
- Went 2-1 at the Sun Devil Classic with Pemberton, collecting a ranked win over the No. 3 pair from No. 6 Cal Poly.
- Went 3-1 at the Cactus Classic with partner Anya Pemberton, picking up wins over the No. 2 pairs from No. 20 Stetson and No. 18 GCU.
- Made her Sun Devil debut against No. 12 Hawai'i, picking up a win at the No. 2 court.
Before ASU
- Played her freshman year at Arizona.
- Was on the top two courts all season for the Wildcats in 2024 as a defender, going 18-15 and being ranked in the top 20 for the majority of the year. She went 7-2 at the No. 2 spot and 11-13 at the ones.
- She helped the team be ranked for the majority of the season and clinched the upset over Grand Canyon.
- Before college, she was honorable mention for the AVCA Junior Beach All-America list in 2023 and was named to the Fab 50 list by VolleyballMag.com.
- At William H. Hough High School, she played four years of indoor volleyball, two years of basketball and one season of track and field (long jump, high jump).
- In indoor volleyball, she won four conference championships and was named to the 4A All-State Team as a senior. She also was All-Lake Player of the Year.
- It wasn't until her sophomore year that she started beach volleyball, playing for Sinjin Beach Club in Raleigh, North Carolina.
Personal
Her parents are Terri and Jeff McElroy, and she has one older sister named Savannah.
McElroy's career summary
| Year | Record |
| 2026 | 9-5 |
| 2025 | 19-16 |
| 2024* | 18-15 |
| Total | 46-36 |
*at Arizona